Puzzle Potluck 4

Solution – Campsite → Nook's Cranny
ANSWER – BALLOON
by Rajeev Nayak

Part 1 (Guidebook)

The puzzle page contains a checklist that the puzzle writer was supposed to complete before the hunt started, but it looks like they forgot to add the actual puzzle contents to the website in time! However, the last few checklist items seem to imply that the solution is on the website and might be accessible.

There isn't a link to the solution on the puzzle page, but it's not too hard to guess that the URL for the solution is probably similar to the puzzle URL but with the word solution added in somewhere. Sure enough, tacking on /solution to the end of the puzzle URL leads to the "solution" for this puzzle. (This also matches the format of solution URLs from previous Puzzle Potlucks.)

The "solution" describes a series of transformations that were applied to a 6x6 grid of words, and it contains enough information to reconstruct what the original puzzle should have looked like. The most rigorous way to go about this is to start with the final state and work backwards step-by-step, undoing one transformation at a time (although it's also not too hard to do it without going strictly in reverse order). Here's a walkthrough of how to reverse all the steps, starting with the final state of grids 1, 2, and 3 (grid 4 was never transformed so it doesn't need to be considered):

7510
495
763
RESTSHUFFLEENGAGEMENT
NOODLESMOGDOT
MOODGIMLIRATTLE
PEB
ISE
RML

Step 4.11: After reading through all the convoluted text, it turns out this step just transformed CANARY to BENEDICT. There are no 8-letter words in grid 1, so BENEDICT must have been the B in grid 3. That means CANARY was there before step 4.11 was applied.

7510
495
763
RESTSHUFFLEENGAGEMENT
NOODLESMOGDOT
MOODGIMLIRATTLE
PECANARY
ISE
RML

Step 4.10: There are only two words in grid 2 with double letters that could have been swapped to make two new words: SHUTTLE and RAFFLE → SHUFFLE and RATTLE.

7510
495
763
RESTSHUTTLEENGAGEMENT
NOODLESMOGDOT
MOODGIMLIRAFFLE
PECANARY
ISE
RML

Step 4.9: The only anagram of REINVENTING is INTERVENING, which is 11 letters long and starts with I, so it must have been the I in grid 3.

7510
495
763
RESTSHUTTLEENGAGEMENT
NOODLESMOGDOT
MOODGIMLIRAFFLE
PECANARY
REINVENTINGSE
RML

Step 4.8 and 4.7: It's easiest to look at steps 4.8 and 4.7 at the same time, since they use the four names mentioned in one of the Author's Notes at the bottom. The only way to satisfy step 4.7 is to insert IDA inside HOLLY to get HOLLIDAY, so that leaves TRUTH → RUTH and EARLY → EARL for step 4.8. Here's where things start to get tricky, because all of these words could fit in multiple squares (e.g. EARL could have been the 4-letter word or either of the Es). We'll write them in as possibilities (kind of like solving a Sudoku) and they'll eventually get disambiguated later.

75 [HOLLIDAY]10
4 [TRUTH/EARLY]95 [HOLLIDAY]
763
RESTSHUTTLEENGAGEMENT
NOODLESMOGDOT
MOODGIMLIRAFFLE
PE [EARLY]CANARY
REINVENTINGSE [EARLY]
R [TRUTH]ML

Step 4.6: Jumping back to step 3.11 for a second, it's clear that the character name that came out of that was GIMLI. The word above it is SMOG, which is an (almost) homophone of SMAUG.

75 [HOLLIDAY]10
4 [TRUTH/EARLY]95 [HOLLIDAY]
763
RESTSHUTTLEENGAGEMENT
NOODLESMAUGDOT
MOODGIMLIRAFFLE
PE [EARLY]CANARY
REINVENTINGSE [EARLY]
R [TRUTH]ML

Step 4.5: The only 10-letter word in grid 2 is ENGAGEMENT, so that must have been one of the results of this step. The only other common 10-letter word with the same letter bank is MANAGEMENT, the 6-letter word with that letter bank is MAGNET, and the 9-letter word with that letter bank plus a U and a D is AUGMENTED. Therefore, the transformations were AUGMENTED → ENGAGEMENT and MANAGEMENT → MAGNET. It's given that MAGNET is in grid 3, so it must have been the M.

75 [HOLLIDAY]10
4 [TRUTH/EARLY]95 [HOLLIDAY]
763
RESTSHUTTLEAUGMENTED
NOODLESMAUGDOT
MOODGIMLIRAFFLE
PE [EARLY]CANARY
REINVENTINGSE [EARLY]
R [TRUTH]MANAGEMENTL

Step 4.4: Looking back to step 3.5, it can be quickly figured out that the output of that step was FUSION. Caesar shifting it by 6 results in LAYOUT, which could have been either the 6-letter word or the L.

75 [HOLLIDAY]10
4 [TRUTH/EARLY]95 [HOLLIDAY]
76 [FUSION]3
RESTSHUTTLEAUGMENTED
NOODLESMAUGDOT
MOODGIMLIRAFFLE
PE [EARLY]CANARY
REINVENTINGSE [EARLY]
R [TRUTH]MANAGEMENTL [FUSION]

Step 4.3: Step 3.10 mentions that the word TV is in the grid, so that's the 2-letter abbreviation that was expanded to TELEVISION (which must have been the 10-letter word in grid 1). There are no 1-letter words in grid 1, so the drug abbreviation must be one of the letters in grid 3 (P, E, S, R, or L); the only common drug abbreviation is ECSTASY → E. Finally, the only day of the week whose 3-letter abbreviation reverses to another English word is WEDNESDAY, which must have been the 9-letter word in grid 1.

75 [HOLLIDAY]TV
4 [TRUTH/EARLY]WED5 [HOLLIDAY]
76 [FUSION]3
RESTSHUTTLEAUGMENTED
NOODLESMAUGDOT
MOODGIMLIRAFFLE
PE [EARLY/ECSTASY]CANARY
REINVENTINGSE [EARLY/ECSTASY]
R [TRUTH]MANAGEMENTL [FUSION]

Step 4.2: The 3-letter word reversal resulted in WED, so the original word was DEW. Since the output of 3.11 was GIMLI, the letter-swapped word from step 4.1 must have been one of the three words to the left of GIMLI. The only one of those words that is reversible is MOOD, so the original word was DOOM.

75 [HOLLIDAY]TV
4 [TRUTH/EARLY]DEW5 [HOLLIDAY]
76 [FUSION]3
RESTSHUTTLEAUGMENTED
NOODLESMAUGDOT
DOOMGIMLIRAFFLE
PE [EARLY/ECSTASY]CANARY
REINVENTINGSE [EARLY/ECSTASY]
R [TRUTH]MANAGEMENTL [FUSION]

Step 4.1: There's only one way the first letters could have been swapped between the three words to the left of GIMLI: NEST → REST, DOODLE → NOODLE, and ROOM → DOOM.

75 [HOLLIDAY]TV
4 [TRUTH/EARLY]DEW5 [HOLLIDAY]
76 [FUSION]3
NESTSHUTTLEAUGMENTED
DOODLESMAUGDOT
ROOMGIMLIRAFFLE
PE [EARLY/ECSTASY]CANARY
REINVENTINGSE [EARLY/ECSTASY]
R [TRUTH]MANAGEMENTL [FUSION]

Step 3.11: Looking at the (fake) solution from Puzzle Potluck 0.01 (which never existed), this transformation must have been DWARF → GIMLI.

75 [HOLLIDAY]TV
4 [TRUTH/EARLY]DEW5 [HOLLIDAY]
76 [FUSION]3
NESTSHUTTLEAUGMENTED
DOODLESMAUGDOT
ROOMDWARFRAFFLE
PE [EARLY/ECSTASY]CANARY
REINVENTINGSE [EARLY/ECSTASY]
R [TRUTH]MANAGEMENTL [FUSION]

Step 3.10: The only main character of Family Guy who is referred to by his last name and has a one-word catchphrase is Quagmire. His catchphrase is GIGGITY, which must have been one of the 7-letter words in grid 1.

7 [QUAGMIRE]5 [HOLLIDAY]TV
4 [TRUTH/EARLY]DEW5 [HOLLIDAY]
7 [QUAGMIRE]6 [FUSION]3
NESTSHUTTLEAUGMENTED
DOODLESMAUGDOT
ROOMDWARFRAFFLE
PE [EARLY/ECSTASY]CANARY
REINVENTINGSE [EARLY/ECSTASY]
R [TRUTH]MANAGEMENTL [FUSION]

Step 3.9: The only 3-letter numbers are ONE, TWO, SIX, and TEN. The only 7-letter word that contains GACT plus one of those 3-letter strings in order is COGNATE (the strings TWO and TEN can also be ruled out because they contain a letter from GACT). ONE must have been the 3-letter word in grid 1.

7 [QUAGMIRE]5 [HOLLIDAY]TV
4 [TRUTH/EARLY]DEW5 [HOLLIDAY]
7 [QUAGMIRE]6 [FUSION]COGNATE
NESTSHUTTLEAUGMENTED
DOODLESMAUGDOT
ROOMDWARFRAFFLE
PE [EARLY/ECSTASY]CANARY
REINVENTINGSE [EARLY/ECSTASY]
R [TRUTH]MANAGEMENTL [FUSION]

Step 3.8: The Japanese flag can be described as a DOT, so the word JAPAN can be placed there. (Another plausible description could be SUN, but the S in grid 3 will be claimed by another word later anyways.)

7 [QUAGMIRE]5 [HOLLIDAY]TV
4 [TRUTH/EARLY]DEW5 [HOLLIDAY]
7 [QUAGMIRE]6 [FUSION]COGNATE
NESTSHUTTLEAUGMENTED
DOODLESMAUGJAPAN
ROOMDWARFRAFFLE
PE [EARLY/ECSTASY]CANARY
REINVENTINGSE [EARLY/ECSTASY]
R [TRUTH]MANAGEMENTL [FUSION]

Step 3.7: Step 4.11 mentioned that the word DRAKE had been transformed in an earlier step. The Drake music video that inspired memes was HOTLINE BLING. The only place those two words could fit horizontally adjacent is the 7 and 5 in grid 1. This also clears up the placement for HOLLIDAY and QUAGMIRE.

DRAKEMEMETV
4 [TRUTH/EARLY]DEWHOLLIDAY
QUAGMIRE6 [FUSION]COGNATE
NESTSHUTTLEAUGMENTED
DOODLESMAUGJAPAN
ROOMDWARFRAFFLE
PE [EARLY/ECSTASY]CANARY
REINVENTINGSE [EARLY/ECSTASY]
R [TRUTH]MANAGEMENTL [FUSION]

Step 3.6: Glancing back to step 3.2, the output was an actor's last name. The only reasonable option that starts with the name of a face card and ends with SON is JACKSON, so this step transformed JACKSON → PRINCE (the son of a king and queen). PRINCE could have either been the 6-letter word or the P.

DRAKEMEMETV
4 [TRUTH/EARLY]DEWHOLLIDAY
QUAGMIRE6 [FUSION/JACKSON]COGNATE
NESTSHUTTLEAUGMENTED
DOODLESMAUGJAPAN
ROOMDWARFRAFFLE
P [JACKSON]E [EARLY/ECSTASY]CANARY
REINVENTINGSE [EARLY/ECSTASY]
R [TRUTH]MANAGEMENTL [FUSION]

Step 3.5: One of the Author's Notes mentions that the Yu-Gi-Oh! card Polymerization is referenced in this puzzle. Polymerization is used to summon fusion monsters, so this step transformed POLYMERIZATION → FUSION. We already had two potential squares for FUSION, and this doesn't help clear that up yet.

DRAKEMEMETV
4 [TRUTH/EARLY]DEWHOLLIDAY
QUAGMIRE6 [POLYMERIZATION / JACKSON]COGNATE
NESTSHUTTLEAUGMENTED
DOODLESMAUGJAPAN
ROOMDWARFRAFFLE
P [JACKSON]E [EARLY/ECSTASY]CANARY
REINVENTINGSE [EARLY/ECSTASY]
R [TRUTH]MANAGEMENTL [POLYMERIZATION]

Step 3.4: The output of this step is Volcanion's signature move STEAM ERUPTION (which must have been the horizontally adjacent S and E in grid 3), but the inputs to this step are a bit more unclear. Volcanion's two types are fire and water. The text implies that one of those types has a molecule that's comprised of 3 elements, so that must be water (H20). Therefore, the word on the left must have been FIRE and the word on the right was the word referenced in step 3.1. Placing these also finally clears up EARLY, TRUTH, and ECSTASY.

DRAKEMEMETV
EARLYDEWHOLLIDAY
QUAGMIRE6 [POLYMERIZATION / JACKSON]COGNATE
NESTSHUTTLEAUGMENTED
DOODLESMAUGJAPAN
ROOMDWARFRAFFLE
P [JACKSON]ECSTASYCANARY
REINVENTINGFIRE(Step 3.1 word)
TRUTHMANAGEMENTL [POLYMERIZATION]

Step 3.3: The only villagers in Animal Crossing: New Horizons that contain the string ROCK are Rocket and Sprocket, so this transformation must have been BLANKET → ROCKET (unless spblanket is a word?). ROCKET must have been the 6-letter word in grid 1, which clears up JACKSON and POLYMERIZATION.

DRAKEMEMETV
EARLYDEWHOLLIDAY
QUAGMIREBLANKETCOGNATE
NESTSHUTTLEAUGMENTED
DOODLESMAUGJAPAN
ROOMDWARFRAFFLE
JACKSONECSTASYCANARY
REINVENTINGFIRE(Step 3.1 word)
TRUTHMANAGEMENTPOLYMERIZATION

Step 3.2: Samuel Jackson played Nick Fury in the MCU movies, so this transformation was FURY → JACKSON.

DRAKEMEMETV
EARLYDEWHOLLIDAY
QUAGMIREBLANKETCOGNATE
NESTSHUTTLEAUGMENTED
DOODLESMAUGJAPAN
ROOMDWARFRAFFLE
FURYECSTASYCANARY
REINVENTINGFIRE(Step 3.1 word)
TRUTHMANAGEMENTPOLYMERIZATION

Step 3.1: The very first (or last in this case) step is the most complicated. We need to find a word that can be broken down into 9 concatenated element abbreviations, and from step 3.4 we know that the 3rd, 7th, and 8th elements are H, H, and O in some order. The Author's Notes mention that interpreting the element abbreviation lengths as Morse code spells the word ZEST, so the pattern of lengths must be 2, 2, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 2. This means that the full word has the letter pattern ????H???HO??, ????H???OH??, or ????O???HH??. There are a few common words that fit one of these patterns (neighborhood, arachnophobe, daughterhood, etc), but the only one that can be broken down into the correct pattern of elements is ArAcHNOPHOBe. That was fun, right?

DRAKEMEMETV
EARLYDEWHOLLIDAY
QUAGMIREBLANKETCOGNATE
NESTSHUTTLEAUGMENTED
DOODLESMAUGJAPAN
ROOMDWARFRAFFLE
FURYECSTASYCANARY
REINVENTINGFIREARACHNOPHOBE
TRUTHMANAGEMENTPOLYMERIZATION

Putting these together with the unaltered grid 4 produces the full 6x6 grid, which is what the Guidebook puzzle should have looked like in the first place. If only the author remembered to add it to the website!

DRAKEMEMETVNESTSHUTTLEAUGMENTED
EARLYDEWHOLLIDAYDOODLESMAUGJAPAN
QUAGMIREBLANKETCOGNATEROOMDWARFRAFFLE
FURYECSTASYCANARYARCHIPELAGOINCENSEHOSPITAL
REINVENTINGFIREARACHNOPHOBESNOWCAPPEDDEPRESSIONSUMMERTIME
TRUTHMANAGEMENTPOLYMERIZATIONINDOCHINESEEMPTINESSDOMINANCE

Part 2 (Board Game)

Using the grid of words from Guidebook, each Codenames key card highlights 3 red clued words and 3 blue clued words. Each set of 3 clued words can be used to guess what the red and blue teams' clues were for each card.

The red and blue clues for each card correspond to red and blue items from a well-known group of colored things. There is a third clue for each card: the item in the group that matches the color underneath the card (the cards are ordered alphabetically by these third clues). Just like the red and blue clues were cluing words in the grid, the third colored clues each clue a single word in the grid.

Red wordsRed clueBlue wordsBlue clueGroupThird clueThird word
FURY
INCENSE
MANAGEMENT
ANGER
DEPRESSION
SUMMERTIME
EMPTINESS
SADNESSInside OutJOYECSTASY
TV
AUGMENTED
TRUTH
REALITY
SHUTTLE
ROOM
EMPTINESS
SPACEInfinity StonesPOWERDOMINANCE
DOODLE
ROOM
RAFFLE
DRAWING
HOLLIDAY
DWARF
HOSPITAL
DOCGoogle DriveSHEETBLANKET
DEW
SMAUG
SNOWCAPPED
MOUNTAIN
CANARY
ARCHIPELAGO
FIRE
ISLANDMagic: The Gathering manaSWAMPQUAGMIRE
NEST
EARLY
CANARY
BIRD
DRAKE
SMAUG
FIRE
DRAGONThe Four SymbolsTIGERINDOCHINESE

Using the numbers at the bottom to index into the third words spells the phrase REDLUCKYCHARM. The red marshmallow in Lucky Charms is a BALLOON, which is the answer to this puzzle.


Author's Notes

  • The high-level idea for Guidebook came from the two-part puzzle format — I thought it would be cool to have the first part start with a solution and end with the original puzzle contents (so the second part could then use the original puzzle to get the real solution). To bring the "backsolve from solution" idea to life, I drew a lot of inspiration from the mechanics of An Erratic Puzzle and the silly solutions from Ten Years Later (specifically The Super Bowl minipuzzle), both from Galactic Puzzle Hunt 2019. I later realized that both of those puzzles had the same author, so thank you Anderson for the inspiration and the fun puzzles!
  • The step in Guidebook that transformed DWARF to GIMLI originally referenced an actual puzzle from Puzzle Potluck 3 (if you did it, you might be able to remember which puzzle it was). When Curtis test-solved it, he pointed out that some solvers might not appreciate the spoilers, and suggested the idea of making a fake solution to a fake puzzle instead. That was great feedback, because the fake solution ended up being potentially my favorite thing that I wrote for this puzzle.
  • After deciding that the output of Guidebook would be a grid of words, it felt very natural to lead into a Codenames puzzle. I was pretty happy with the color-based mechanic that I came up with, although after I finished writing this puzzle there was a similar mechanic used in a metapuzzle from another hunt earlier in 2021. Hopefully this puzzle was different enough that it still felt fresh!
  • It was surprisingly hard to find groups of colored things whose names are common English words that can be used as Codenames clues (this eliminated groups like Power Rangers or subway lines in various cities). Another constraint was that the red and blue words had to uniquely identify a single group, so pairs like FIRE and WATER that appear in many groups were also off the table.
  • It was extremely lucky (pun intended?) that one of the puzzle answers we needed was an item in a colored group of things. I even happened to pick BALLOON out of the set of answers when I started writing this, because I thought it made the most sense for the Codenames puzzle to be in Nook's Cranny. As I was racking my brain for groups of colored things, I thought of Lucky Charms, started writing the items in my spreadsheet, and realized "Wait...I just wrote down the answer to the puzzle!" It ended up being a perfectly thematic final clue.
  • Best Wrong Answers:
    Wrong AnswerSubmitted by:
    NONEmany teams
    COOKIECRISPwhereswaldo
    FROSTEDCHEERIOWhite Maria
    IMGLADTHATTHERESNOGUESSLIMITBlobble

Stats

  • 320 solves
  • 669 incorrect guesses
  • Most common incorrect guess: REDLUCKYCHARM (guessed 121 times)
  • First solve: apractic pacesetters in 1 hour, 57 minutes, and 35 seconds