Puzzle Potluck 4

Solution – Garden → Airport
ANSWER – COLONY
by Lindsey Shi and Rajeev Nayak

Part 1 (Red Roses)

Each poem follows the format of a Roses are Red meme, where the final line of the poem is specified by an image and the second line is a somewhat random phrase that rhymes with that final line. Each image in this puzzle is a meme / relatively well-known quote — it can be filled in with one word per blank to form the final line of the poem (the poems are ordered alphabetically by the final line). The two blanks in the second line can then be guessed, knowing that the last word must rhyme with the final line.

Roses are red
A store partially owned by Meek Mill is called Lids
And I would have gotten away with it, too, if it weren't for you meddling kids
Roses are red
District 12's escort is Effie
Despite the constant negative press covfefe
Las rosas son rojas
La Kaaba es un santuario en La Meca
¿Dónde está la biblioteca?
Roses are red
Tenzin's flying bison is Oogi
Draw your last pathetic card so I can end this, Yugi
Roses are red
One of the largest eels is the conger
Fusion is just a cheap tactic to make weak gems stronger
Roses are red
At Starbucks, eight ounces is a short
I am once again asking for your financial support
Roses are red
A female sheep is a ewe
I was rooting for you, we were all rooting for you! How dare you?!
Roses are red
F major has one flat
I'm here live, I'm not a cat
Roses are red
Daisy is the first name of the actress who plays Finn's friend Rey
Legit question for rural Americans - how do I kill the 30-50 feral hogs that run into my yard within 3-5 mins while my small kids play?
Roses are red
From 1987, Burton portrayed La Forge
Raise your hand if you’ve ever been personally victimized by Regina George
Roses are red
Paris's river is the Seine
Team Rocket's blasting off again
Roses are red
Curly is a wavy-leaved variety of kale
You undercook fish? Believe it or not, jail

Part 2 (Transfer Desk)

The answer to each clue is one letter off from one of the words filled into a blank in the second line of a Red Roses poem. This insight is needed to narrow down most of these underspecified / ambiguous clues.

ClueAnswerRed Roses WordNew Letter
1MisdirectDISTRACTDISTRICTA
2Cuteness benchmarkBUTTONBURTONT
3PorridgeCONGEECONGERE
4Greek house, perhapsFRATFLATR
5Central Park locale Harlem _____MEERMEEKR
6He appears in the other part of this taskKAIBAKAABAI
7Horror novelistSTINESEINET
8Something the person below does wellSHOOTSHORTO
9Warriors' guardCURRYCURLYR
10AsceticYOGIOOGIY
11Outdoor poolLIDOLIDSO
12Bob and HelenPARRSPARISR
13Pretty okay, slangilyAIGHTEIGHTA
14Comes togetherGELSEELSG
15UnmitigatedSHEERSHEEPR
16100-yen shopDAISODAISYO
17Artist formerly signed to Ed Banger RecordsUFFIEEFFIEU
18A variety of sport, or one of its componentsTENPINTENZINP
19Refrain fromFORGOFORGEO
20Zebra (abbr.)REFREYF
21ImpressAWEEWEA
22Briarcliff or Wayne, for instanceMANORMAJORN
23Jack's counterpart, with respect to Spades?KATEKALET
24Certain ridge, or a city where you might find oneMESAMECAS

Reading the new letters that were "transferred" into the words spells the phrase "A territory or a group of ants," which clues the final answer to this puzzle, COLONY.


Authors' Notes

  • Like most Lindsey/Rajeev collaborations, this puzzle started with Lindsey randomly messaging Rajeev: "Roses are red / One of the largest __ is the __ / [the Steven Universe image]." We ended up keeping this example in the final version of the puzzle.
  • The first draft of Red Roses had three separate columns, one with all of the first lines, one with all of the second lines, and one with all of the images. That proved to be extremely difficult, and test-solvers ended up having to backsolve almost all of it from Transfer Desk, which is not the solve path we intended. After a couple more iterations, we ended up going back to the very original format that Lindsey sent to Rajeev in the first place.
  • We used the initial clip in this video to determine the canonical pronunciation of "covfefe" for rhyming purposes.
  • The Tyra Banks rant was the original inspiration for Tools (see the Authors' Notes for more details), so we're glad that we were able to sneak in a reference to it in this puzzle.
  • Best Wrong Answers:
    Wrong AnswerSubmitted by:
    ABUGSLIFE:praytrick:
    ENTMOOTPuzzanauts
    VAPEJUICEAmaranth

Stats

  • 336 solves
  • 131 incorrect guesses
  • Most common incorrect guess: ARMY (guessed 7 times)
  • First solve: Have you tried adding butter? in 1 hour, 12 minutes, and 43 seconds